Listen up, Hunger Games fanatics: I hear that Snow White and the Huntsman‘s resident Prince Charming Sam Claflin has been selected to play sexy tribute Finnick Odair in the second installment of the trilogy, Catching Fire. I was rooting for Armie Hammer or Garrett Hedlund to snag the role–Sam is cute in that goofy British way, but can you really picture him oiled up with a net and trident, fighting to the death? Better hit the gym, Sammy… or the odds will not be in your favor during the filming.

WENN